How the Coronavirus Changes the Openness of Governments: Analytical Portals and New Platforms for Dialogue with Citizens

Press center
May 18, 2020


Improving accountability of authorities and personal responsibility of department heads and organisations to society for the achievement of goals and objectives is one of the key principles of the Development Strategy of the Accounts Chamber of the Russian Federation. This digest shows how the idea of openness has changed in the face of the pandemic. 

In many countries SAIs follow the principles of transparency and openness. They unanimously adopted the Moscow Declaration at the INCOSAI and agreed to promote more efficient, transparent government agencies and the principles of data availability and openness of source code and algorithms. 

1. Open Government Criteria

According to the OECD principles, an open government means that citizens, businesses and civil society organisations can

  • know – obtain relevant and understandable information;

  • acquire – obtain public services and interact with the government;

  • create – participate in decision-making.

The same approach is applied in Russia. For example, the concept of open government in the report Open Government in Russia of 2019 prepared by the Accounts Chamber together with the Autonomous Non-Commercial Organization "Infocultura" and the Center for Advanced Governance is based on three key elements:

  • openness of information;

  • functional openness (open data);

  • open dialogue.

2. Openness of Information

During the COVID-19 pandemic, special focus has been placed on the transparency of budget expenditures to combat the impact of the epidemic. Supreme Audit Institutions provide their independent assessment of the government’s performance in this regard.

The French Court of Auditors has published the report of the High Council for Public Finances on its website on the epidemic-related amendments to the 2020 State Budget: the high level of uncertainty associated with the health crisis affects all macroeconomic forecasts and leads to their frequent revision.

The SAI of Germany has prepared an analytical report “Federal Budget Policy Measures to Combat the Impact of the Coronavirus Pandemic (Key Figures for the 2020 Supplementary Budget)” reflecting the changes associated with extra funds allocated to combat the epidemic and the adoption of a new crisis package.

The SAI of Brazil has started monitoring the efforts made by all federal administrations to combat the spread of COVID-19. The special plan for monitoring COVID-19 measures expands the scope of control of public institutions beyond the Ministry of Health.

3. Functional Openness

In light of the current situation, functional openness is illustrated by open data on public procurement conducted in a short time with simplified procedures. There are scheduled audits, separate monitoring on each issue and information panels, including the aggregator website Gosraskhody (State Expenditures), a service of the Accounts Chamber designed to collect current information on the state of the public procurement system in Russia.

The SAI of Cyprus has analysed public contracts of the Ministry of Health with private medical centers to test 20 thousand public and private sector employees for SARS CoV-2. The analysis revealed an overpricing of the tests, as well as risks of oligopoly or unfair competition.

The SAI of the Czech Republic started to audit public procurement of personal protective equipment during the state of emergency, for which CZK 11 billion ($430 million) was spent from the state budget.

The Accounts Chamber of the Russian Federation presented a report “Assessment of Openness of State Information Systems in Russia” in March. Experts found that only 16% of state information systems had high-quality and accessible data. The quality of data in state information systems became particularly important during a pandemic, said Aleksei Kudrin, Chairman of the Accounts Chamber, in an interview.

4. Open Dialogue

In the face of the COVID-19 epidemic, it is important to carefully coordinate policy-making, consider specific features of regions, cities and opinions of particular citizens. In this situation, open dialogue enables citizens to influence social and economic policies and political decision-making processes in their countries.

The government of Slovenia agrees on new steps to lift restrictions with union representatives every seven days, depending on the needs of each industry and each profession.

The SAI of Peru has developed an online platform for citizens to report wrongdoings and has launched an online office to receive and register public authorities’ documents during the state of emergency.

5. Social media, blogs and games as tools for openness

The way information is consumed is constantly changing. Specific features of different channels need to be considered in order to facilitate access to useful information that helps to develop taxpayer sentiments in more people and share government results with new audiences.

The SAI of Colombia regularly posts relevant information on countering COVID-19 on its Twitter account.

Gareth Davies, Head of the UK SAI, tells about the SAI’s response to the COVID-19 pandemic on his blog.

The SAI of Mexico has developed a children’s game app about public administration, audit, the public, gender equality, inclusion.

Read the full version of the digest here.

Press center
May 11, 2020


How the Coronavirus Changes Work of SAIs: Suspended Audits and Greater Transparency

A guideline for supreme audit institutions, the Moscow Declaration, says that "SAIs need to respond to a changing world of governance and, in doing so, respond to emerging national and global challenges." Learn below how audit agencies from around the globe adhere to this principle in the midst of the pandemic.

Press center
April 27, 2020


How the Coronavirus Changes Social Services: Putting into Practice the Principle of Leaving No One Behind

Vulnerable people always need special attention, for example, the disabled, the homeless, orphans, the unemployed, prisoners and many others. In short, all those who objectively need support at any time.

Press center
April 20, 2020


How the Coronavirus Changes Education: Gobal Problems and Other Countries Experience

UNESCO, OECD and the World Bank have conducted studies on how education is changing in the era of self-isolation and quarantine. In a few paragraphs, we describe how the governments around the world cope with these challenges.